I read the part of Peggy who, in the Pilot, is conservative and plain (for the 50's) so that is how I dressed. I wore flat boots, a black pencil skirt, a red scoop shirt (which happens to be my best friend's shirt), and a wide black belt. I do own some 50's style dresses but they didn't go with the character. I wore simple faux pearl studs and faux pearl necklace to complete the look.
I kept my eye makeup simple and used Stila's 'Kitten' as an all over shimmery base. I really like the texture of this eye shadow and how well it goes on. I have not had any fall out with this eye shadow, and it applies like a dream! I then used the Color Tattoo pigment color in 'Breaking Bronze' in the crease and the outer 'V' of my eye. This is a lot deeper than 'Kitten' but still in the same color family, so they complimented each other quite nicely.